• English
  • 中文
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Gplus
  • Linkedin
  • Mail
  • Rss

Lisiming.net

  • Chinese
    Philosophy
    • Confucius
    • Daoism
      • Daoist Basics
        • Yin-Yang Bagua System
        • Five Element System
        • Essence-Energy-Spirit System
        • Energy System in Body
        • Daoist Regimen
      • Daoist Philosophy
        • Dao De Jing core 33 Chapters
        • Why select 33 Chapters from Laozi
        • Summary of Laozi core 33 Chapters
        • Qing Jing Jing
      • Daoist Cultivation
        • 4 types of human
        • 5 types of immortals
        • Internal Alchemy: An Overview
        • ZhangSanFeng Teachings
    • Buddhist
      • Buddhist Basics
      • Buddhist Cultivation
        • 6 Paramitas
      • Buddhist Teachings
        • The Heart Sutra
        • The Diamond Sutra
        • The Zen Teachings of Bodhidharma
          • Outline of Practice
          • Wake-up Sermon
  • Spiritual
    Cultivation
    • 4-Stage Development
    • 3 Pathways
    • Meditation
    • Related Topics
    • Modern Research
      • Messages from Water
      • The Master Key System
      • Map of Consciousness
  • Study with
    Derek
    • Derek’s Approach
    • Individual/group class
    • US tour May 2013
    • US Tour April 2014
    • 12 Day Heart of China Cultural Spiritual Tour
    • 100-Hour Chinese Spirituality Foundation Program
    • Testimonials
    • Newsletter Sign Up
    • Contact
  • Blog /
    Online Class
    • Blog
    • News
    • Online Class
    • Archives

Blog

Diamond Sutra – Is there merit? Is there no merit?

12/01/2013
12/01/2013

In chapter 8 of this Sutra, the Buddha said blessings of sharing this Sutra far surpass that of any worldly offerings.   Is it really so?  Can we acquire this great merit or huge blessings for sharing the wisdom of this Sutra?  The Buddha continues in this chapter: if the real merit can be described, it is not the real merit.  Based on the discussion we have so far, do you understand why? Is there merit?  Is there no merit?

* * *

法界通化分第十九

UNDERSTANDING AND TRANSFORMING THE DHARMA REALM, NINETEEN

须菩提!于意云何?若有人满三千大千世界七宝以用布施,是人以是因缘,得福多不?
“Subhuti, what do you think? If someone filled the universe with the seven treasures and gave all away in his practice of dana, would this (good) cause enable the giver to gain a great merit?”

如是,世尊!此人以是因缘,得福甚多。
“Yes, World Honoured One, because of this (good) cause the giver would gain a great merit.”

须菩提,若福德有实,如来不说得福德多;以福德无故,如来说得福德多。
“’Subhuti, if the merit was real, the Tathagata would not say it was great. He says so because there is no merit.”

Tags: Blessings, merit, 福德
4 Comments/in Buddhist, Chinese Philosophy, Online Class /by Derek
Related Entries
universes

Diamond Sutra – Blessings and Wisdom...

buddha assembly

Diamond Sutra – the mystical presence...

Diamond Sutra – All Buddhas and their Supreme-Enlightenment-Dharma originate from this Sutra

Diamond Sutra – All Buddhas and their...

4 replies
  1. 妮姬 says:
    12/01/2013 at 09:56

    Is not even the concept of merit due to good actions flawed in that it associates reward/ benefit with good actions? Philosophically, are not true meritorious deeds ones that are done from a sense of loving kindness/ compassion with no expectation of benefit, reward, recognition, or even the expectation that the action itself will be judged as being meritorious?

    Reply
    • Derek says:
      12/01/2013 at 10:05

      Good observation. Indeed, pure virtuous actions are unconditional and are without agenda or expectation, just like the Daoist description of pure virtue is like water. Yet, just because pure virtue are unconditional, can we conclude that virtue or merit does not exist as a result of loving kindness?

      Reply
  2. 妮姬 says:
    12/02/2013 at 02:55

    Surely virtue and merit must exist as a result of loving kindness, but if one attaches one’s self to it in any way or form.. is the action still one of true virtue and merit?

    As you say, is this not the same as with the Dao? We can discuss it and there is great value in that, but at the same time we must acknowledge that the true experience of Dao is not that which is described in words.

    Is this not the same as practicing Kung Fu? One can not learn Kung Fu from reading about it in books or watching movies. Nor can one completely understand it by watching somebody else, no matter how good they are. One must experience it. Perhaps in this way it is like the Dao. Also one can not own or completely control the experience of Kung Fu. It happens in it’s own time and space after much investment of time and effort on our part to cultivate it. Perhaps in this way it is like loving kindness leading to actions of merit and virtue. These actions are not ours, they do not originate completely from us, but they flow through us like wind flowing through a flute. The wind/air is not ours to own… we only instruments helping shape it into music.

    Reply
    • Derek says:
      12/02/2013 at 21:50

      ”like wind flowing through a flute… and we are only instruments that help shape it into music” – this is such beautiful analogy… If only we can have more of us who allow this loving wind to blow at more time, what will the world become? The understanding is close, the direction is right.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Contact

To conact Derek you can use the contact Form on the Contact Page.

Phone - (+86) 133 8714 8778

Links

  • Wudang Dao Institute

Recent Comments

  • Ricardo on Confucius Analects – Balance Work and Study
  • Derek on Dao De Jing core 33 chapters – completed!
  • Georgi Marinov on Dao De Jing core 33 chapters – completed!
  • Derek on Dao De Jing 2 – Dualistic nature of worldly standards, vs. non-dual lifestyle of sages
← Diamond Sutra – Neither the past, the present nor the future mind can be found (previous entry)
(next entry) Diamond Sutra – there is really no Dharma to teach →

Recent Comments

  • Ricardo on Confucius Analects – Balance Work and Study
  • Derek on Dao De Jing core 33 chapters – completed!
  • Georgi Marinov on Dao De Jing core 33 chapters – completed!
  • Derek on Dao De Jing 2 – Dualistic nature of worldly standards, vs. non-dual lifestyle of sages
  • SKent on Diamond Sutra – the mystical presence of this Sutra
  • Sosiale medier – hvorfor markedsføre her? | tdidr on Autobiography of Confucius – Confucius Analects
  • tworzenie stron www kursy kraków on Happy Chinese New Year of the Horse!

Latest News

  • Health Tips during Virus Outbreak03/13/2020 - 11:25
  • lisiming.net01/12/2019 - 11:00
  • New Year01/01/2019 - 11:00
  • ZenZen Reality and Practice12/26/2017 - 19:36
  • Reference from Academia04/19/2015 - 15:35
  • US Tour 2014 – photo04/27/2014 - 12:51
  • practiceOnline Class – foundation course completed03/09/2014 - 10:56

Categories

  • Buddhist
  • Chinese Philosophy
  • Confucianism
  • Daoism
  • Health
  • News
  • Online Class
  • Spiritual Cultivation
  • Uncategorized
  • Wudang

Contact

To contact Derek you can use the Contact Form on the Contact Page.

© Copyright - Lisiming.net - Shimsy Website design